You can add a custom field to the stock.quant model to calculate the financial impact (tested with Odoo 18.0).
Given the following values and costing methods for Products:

The Physical Inventory Menu would then show something like this:

Here, the loss of 1 unit of each product has a financial impact of $29 in lost value.
Custom Field:

Dependencies:
inventory_quantity_set, product_id
Compute:
for record in self:
cost = 0.0
if record.inventory_quantity_set:
product = record.product_id
if product.cost_method in ['standard', 'average']:
cost = product.standard_price
elif product.cost_method == 'fifo':
valuation_layers = record.env['stock.valuation.layer'].search([
('product_id', '=', product.id),('remaining_qty', '>', 0)], order='create_date asc')
qty_to_consume = abs(record.inventory_diff_quantity)
cost = 0.0
for layer in valuation_layers:
if qty_to_consume <= 0:
break
qty_from_layer = min(layer.remaining_qty, qty_to_consume)
cost += qty_from_layer * (layer.unit_cost or 0.0)
qty_to_consume -= qty_from_layer
record['x_impact'] = record.inventory_diff_quantity * cost
Note: this is a prototype, not a solution, and makes assumptions about how products are deplenished from inventory (financial fifo). Your Odoo Digital Advisor or Odoo Partner can help you implement something similar in your own Odoo database. You can also extend this approach to calculate the percentage variance.