Ir al contenido
Odoo Menú
  • Identificarse
  • Pruébalo gratis
  • Aplicaciones
    Finanzas
    • Contabilidad
    • Facturación
    • Gastos
    • Hoja de cálculo (BI)
    • Documentos
    • Firma electrónica
    Ventas
    • CRM
    • Ventas
    • TPV para tiendas
    • TPV para restaurantes
    • Suscripciones
    • Alquiler
    Sitios web
    • Creador de sitios web
    • Comercio electrónico
    • Blog
    • Foro
    • Chat en directo
    • e-learning
    Cadena de suministro
    • Inventario
    • Fabricación
    • PLM
    • Compra
    • Mantenimiento
    • Calidad
    Recursos Humanos
    • Empleados
    • Reclutamiento
    • Ausencias
    • Evaluación
    • Referencias
    • Flota
    Marketing
    • Marketing social
    • Marketing por correo electrónico
    • Marketing por SMS
    • Eventos
    • Automatización de marketing
    • Encuestas
    Servicios
    • Proyecto
    • Partes de horas
    • Servicio de campo
    • Servicio de asistencia
    • Planificación
    • Citas
    Productividad
    • Conversaciones
    • Aprobaciones
    • IoT
    • VoIP
    • Conocimientos
    • WhatsApp
    Aplicaciones de terceros Studio de Odoo Plataforma de Odoo Cloud
  • Industrias
    Comercio al por menor
    • Librería
    • Tienda de ropa
    • Tienda de muebles
    • Tienda de ultramarinos
    • Ferretería
    • Juguetería
    Alimentación y hostelería
    • Bar y pub
    • Restaurante
    • Comida rápida
    • Casa de huéspedes
    • Distribuidor de bebidas
    • Hotel
    Inmueble
    • Agencia inmobiliaria
    • Estudio de arquitectura
    • Construcción
    • Gestión inmobiliaria
    • Jardinería
    • Asociación de propietarios
    Consultoría
    • Empresa contable
    • Partner de Odoo
    • Agencia de marketing
    • Bufete de abogados
    • Adquisición de talentos
    • Auditorías y certificaciones
    Fabricación
    • Textil
    • Metal
    • Muebles
    • Alimentos
    • Cervecería
    • Regalos de empresas
    Salud y bienestar
    • Club deportivo
    • Óptica
    • Gimnasio
    • Terapeutas
    • Farmacia
    • Peluquería
    Oficios
    • Handyman
    • Hardware y soporte técnico
    • Sistemas de energía solar
    • Zapatero
    • Servicios de limpieza
    • Servicios de calefacción, ventilación y aire acondicionado
    Otros
    • Organización sin ánimo de lucro
    • Agencia de protección del medio ambiente
    • Alquiler de paneles publicitarios
    • Estudio fotográfico
    • Alquiler de bicicletas
    • Distribuidor de software
    Explorar todos los sectores
  • Comunidad
    Aprender
    • Tutoriales
    • Documentación
    • Certificaciones
    • Formación
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    Potenciar la educación
    • Programa de formación
    • Scale Up! El juego empresarial
    • Visita Odoo
    Obtener el software
    • Descargar
    • Comparar ediciones
    • Versiones
    Colaborar
    • GitHub
    • Foro
    • Eventos
    • Traducciones
    • Convertirse en partner
    • Servicios para partners
    • Registrar tu empresa contable
    Obtener servicios
    • Encontrar un partner
    • Encontrar un asesor fiscal
    • Contacta con un experto
    • Servicios de implementación
    • Referencias de clientes
    • Ayuda
    • Actualizaciones
    GitHub YouTube Twitter Linkedin Instagram Facebook Spotify
    +1 (650) 691-3277
    Solicitar una demostración
  • Precios
  • Ayuda

Odoo is the world's easiest all-in-one management software.
It includes hundreds of business apps:

  • CRM
  • e-Commerce
  • Contabilidad
  • Inventario
  • PoS
  • Proyecto
  • MRP
All apps
Debe estar registrado para interactuar con la comunidad.
Todas las publicaciones Personas Insignias
Etiquetas (Ver todo)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Acerca de este foro
Debe estar registrado para interactuar con la comunidad.
Todas las publicaciones Personas Insignias
Etiquetas (Ver todo)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Acerca de este foro
Ayuda

Studio or custom module for basic changes? (And other custom dev questions)

Suscribirse

Reciba una notificación cuando haya actividad en esta publicación

Se marcó esta pregunta
2 Respuestas
6366 Vistas
Avatar
Kevin Cackler

We are new to Odoo, but I really like what I've seen so far in playing with it. I think we're going to take the leap to implement it into our business processes, but before I do so, I have a question about how best to implement custom changes. 


For instance, in the CRM, we need to add quite a few new fields, some new tabs, etc... to leads. The easiest way forward would be to just use Studio to add these, but we are also perfectly capable of creating a 'crm_customizations' module and adding them there. Is there any downside to using Studio to make simple changes like this? 


In a similar vein - I have this same question for pretty much every aspect of the software. If we want to add a new model, does that have to be done in the code, or can we just do it from developer mode in Odoo? Or if we want to make a new Server Action, same thing. Can we just throw it in via the web interface and call it good or do we need to add it to our codebase?


Lastly, for now, if we have multiple modules that we're making, what's the typical deployment flow look like? Can these be managed as one git repo or are people creating separate repos for each thing they build, and deploying them separately?


Thanks!

0
Avatar
Descartar
Avatar
Cybrosys Techno Solutions Pvt.Ltd
Mejor respuesta

Hi Kevin,

Using Odoo Studio for making simple changes like adding new fields, tabs, or customizations to existing modules such as CRM leads can be convenient and efficient, especially for users who are not comfortable with coding. It provides a user-friendly interface for making these modifications directly within the application.

However, there are some considerations to keep in mind when using Studio:

  1. Limited Flexibility: While Studio offers a quick way to make changes, it may have limitations compared to custom development. For complex or highly customized requirements, developing a custom module using code might offer more flexibility and control over the functionality.
  2. Version Control: Changes made through Studio are stored in the database and can't be easily version-controlled like code. This can make it harder to track changes over time, especially when multiple users are making modifications simultaneously.
  3. Portability: Customizations made through Studio are tied to the specific database where they are created. If you need to deploy the same changes to another instance or environment, you would need to manually replicate them or use Odoo's data migration tools.

Regarding adding new models or server actions:

  • New models and server actions can also be created using Studio, but once again, it may have limitations compared to custom development, especially for complex business logic or integration requirements.
  • For more advanced or complex functionality, creating custom modules using code allows for greater control and customization. This would involve developing Python code, XML views, and other necessary files to implement the desired features.

For deployment and managing multiple modules:

  • The deployment flow can vary depending on your specific requirements and development practices. Some organizations manage all their custom modules within a single Git repository, while others prefer separate repositories for each module.
  • Managing multiple modules in a single repository can simplify version control and deployment, especially if the modules are closely related or dependent on each other. However, separate repositories offer more granularity and isolation for each module's development and maintenance.

Ultimately, the choice between using Studio and custom development depends on factors such as the complexity of your requirements, the level of control and flexibility needed, and the expertise of your team. It's essential to evaluate the pros and cons of each approach and choose the one that best aligns with your business goals and resources.

Hope it helps

0
Avatar
Descartar
Avatar
Rafeeq Salam
Mejor respuesta

Using Odoo Studio to make simple changes, such as adding fields or tabs in the CRM, is a convenient approach and doesn't necessarily have a downside. However, it's essential to consider a few factors:

Odoo Studio:
  • Pros: Quick and easy modifications, no need for coding skills, immediate implementation.
  • Cons: Changes made in Studio might be more challenging to version control and manage in a team environment. They could also potentially be overwritten during an update or migration.
Custom Module Development:
  • Pros: Offers greater control, easier version control and management, better suited for complex or extensive changes, allows for writing custom code and business logic.
  • Cons: Requires coding skills and knowledge of Odoo development.
Customization Approach:

For small changes, Odoo Studio might suffice. However, for larger or more complex modifications, it's advisable to create a custom module. This approach allows you to have better control over your changes and makes them easier to manage in the long run.

Adding New Models or Server Actions:

Creating new models or server actions can be done both through the web interface (using Developer Mode) and by developing custom modules. For more complex or structured changes, it's often better to implement them through custom modules to maintain control and manage them efficiently.

Deployment and Version Control:

Regarding deployment and version control, there's flexibility in how you manage multiple modules. Some teams prefer managing multiple modules within a single Git repository, especially if the modules are closely related or interdependent. Others prefer separate repositories for better organization and separation of concerns.

Typical Deployment Flow:
  • Single Repository: You can manage multiple modules within a single repository, organizing them into different directories.
  • Separate Repositories: Each module gets its own repository, allowing for independent version control and deployment.
Best Practice:
  • Start Simple: Begin with Odoo Studio for quick changes.
  • Gradually Transition: As your customization needs grow complex or extensive, consider creating custom modules for better control and management.
  • Version Control: Whichever approach you choose, ensure you maintain proper version control to track changes and facilitate collaboration within your team.

Ultimately, the best approach depends on the scale, complexity, and long-term maintenance needs of your customization. It's often helpful to evaluate each scenario to determine the most suitable approach for your specific requirements.


0
Avatar
Descartar
¿Le interesa esta conversación? ¡Participe en ella!

Cree una cuenta para poder utilizar funciones exclusivas e interactuar con la comunidad.

Inscribirse
Comunidad
  • Tutoriales
  • Documentación
  • Foro
Código abierto
  • Descargar
  • GitHub
  • Runbot
  • Traducciones
Servicios
  • Alojamiento Odoo.sh
  • Ayuda
  • Actualizar
  • Desarrollos personalizados
  • Educación
  • Encontrar un asesor fiscal
  • Encontrar un partner
  • Convertirse en partner
Sobre nosotros
  • Nuestra empresa
  • Activos de marca
  • Contacta con nosotros
  • Puestos de trabajo
  • Eventos
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Clientes
  • Información legal • Privacidad
  • Seguridad
الْعَرَبيّة Català 简体中文 繁體中文 (台灣) Čeština Dansk Nederlands English Suomi Français Deutsch हिंदी Bahasa Indonesia Italiano 日本語 한국어 (KR) Lietuvių kalba Język polski Português (BR) română русский язык Slovenský jazyk slovenščina Español (América Latina) Español ภาษาไทย Türkçe українська Tiếng Việt

Odoo es un conjunto de aplicaciones de código abierto que cubren todas las necesidades de tu empresa: CRM, comercio electrónico, contabilidad, inventario, punto de venta, gestión de proyectos, etc.

La propuesta única de valor de Odoo es ser muy fácil de usar y totalmente integrado.

Website made with

Odoo Experience on YouTube

1. Use the live chat to ask your questions.
2. The operator answers within a few minutes.

Live support on Youtube
Watch now