Skip ke Konten
Odoo Menu
  • Login
  • Uji coba gratis
  • Aplikasi
    Keuangan
    • Akuntansi
    • Faktur
    • Pengeluaran
    • Spreadsheet (BI)
    • Dokumen
    • Tanda Tangan
    Sales
    • CRM
    • Sales
    • POS Toko
    • POS Restoran
    • Langganan
    • Rental
    Website
    • Website Builder
    • eCommerce
    • Blog
    • Forum
    • Live Chat
    • eLearning
    Rantai Pasokan
    • Inventaris
    • Manufaktur
    • PLM
    • Purchase
    • Maintenance
    • Kualitas
    Sumber Daya Manusia
    • Karyawan
    • Rekrutmen
    • Cuti
    • Appraisal
    • Referensi
    • Armada
    Marketing
    • Social Marketing
    • Email Marketing
    • SMS Marketing
    • Acara
    • Otomatisasi Marketing
    • Survei
    Layanan
    • Project
    • Timesheet
    • Layanan Lapangan
    • Meja Bantuan
    • Planning
    • Appointment
    Produktivitas
    • Diskusi
    • Approval
    • IoT
    • VoIP
    • Pengetahuan
    • WhatsApp
    Aplikasi pihak ketiga Odoo Studio Platform Odoo Cloud
  • Industri-Industri
    Retail
    • Toko Buku
    • Toko Baju
    • Toko Furnitur
    • Toko Kelontong
    • Toko Hardware
    • Toko Mainan
    Makanan & Hospitality
    • Bar dan Pub
    • Restoran
    • Fast Food
    • Rumah Tamu
    • Distributor Minuman
    • Hotel
    Real Estate
    • Agensi Real Estate
    • Firma Arsitektur
    • Konstruksi
    • Estate Management
    • Perkebunan
    • Asosiasi Pemilik Properti
    Konsultansi
    • Firma Akuntansi
    • Mitra Odoo
    • Agensi Marketing
    • Firma huku
    • Talent Acquisition
    • Audit & Sertifikasi
    Manufaktur
    • Tekstil
    • Logam
    • Perabotan
    • Makanan
    • Brewery
    • Corporate Gift
    Kesehatan & Fitness
    • Sports Club
    • Toko Kacamata
    • Fitness Center
    • Wellness Practitioners
    • Farmasi
    • Salon Rambut
    Perdagangan
    • Handyman
    • IT Hardware & Support
    • Sistem-Sistem Energi Surya
    • Pembuat Sepatu
    • Cleaning Service
    • Layanan HVAC
    Lainnya
    • Organisasi Nirlaba
    • Agen Lingkungan
    • Rental Billboard
    • Fotografi
    • Penyewaan Sepeda
    • Reseller Software
    Browse semua Industri
  • Komunitas
    Belajar
    • Tutorial-tutorial
    • Dokumentasi
    • Sertifikasi
    • Pelatihan
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    Empower Education
    • Program Edukasi
    • Game Bisnis 'Scale Up!'
    • Kunjungi Odoo
    Dapatkan Softwarenya
    • Download
    • Bandingkan Edisi
    • Daftar Rilis
    Kolaborasi
    • Github
    • Forum
    • Acara
    • Terjemahan
    • Menjadi Partner
    • Layanan untuk Partner
    • Daftarkan perusahaan Akuntansi Anda.
    Dapatkan Layanan
    • Temukan Mitra
    • Temukan Akuntan
    • Temui penasihat
    • Layanan Implementasi
    • Referensi Pelanggan
    • Bantuan
    • Upgrades
    Github Youtube Twitter Linkedin Instagram Facebook Spotify
    +1 (650) 691-3277
    Dapatkan demo
  • Harga
  • Bantuan

Odoo is the world's easiest all-in-one management software.
It includes hundreds of business apps:

  • CRM
  • e-Commerce
  • Akuntansi
  • Inventaris
  • PoS
  • Project
  • MRP
All apps
Anda harus terdaftar untuk dapat berinteraksi di komunitas.
Semua Post Orang Lencana-Lencana
Label (Lihat semua)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Mengenai forum ini
Anda harus terdaftar untuk dapat berinteraksi di komunitas.
Semua Post Orang Lencana-Lencana
Label (Lihat semua)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Mengenai forum ini
Help

what are your pros and cons about storing attachments in the filesystem instead of the database?

Langganan

Dapatkan notifikasi saat terdapat aktivitas pada post ini

Pertanyaan ini telah diberikan tanda
databaseattachmentsfilesystem
2 Replies
10707 Tampilan
Avatar
gunnar

here https://www.odoo.com/forum/Help-1/question/Where-are-document-Attachments-stored-529 is a detailed discussion going on about how to have attached files to be stored in the servers file system and not in the database (as it is being done by default).

Can anyone explain what is the advantage? I assume there might be pros and cons for either method and I hope we can gather some arguments here.

1
Avatar
Buang
Avatar
Nigel
Jawaban Terbai

Access, performance, and reliability. They are the tradeoffs to each type.

If you store the files in the database, you have to scale up the database to handle ever increasing data, which also increases the server load. If the database crashes it can be a long nightmare to reconstruct/repair due to the data. Load balancing and sychronizing becomes difficult when the data gets large. BUt you have full control over file security, access rights, the files will always be available, development for access to the files is easier, and file access is faster as they can be indexed.

If files are stored in the filesystem (local, drive, NAS, SAS, etc), you may have dropped links/connections/or concurrent access issues and security rights are also more difficult to enforce. Database recovery and maintianance problems become much easier to deal with, and expanding storage space and redundancy for your files is fairly straight forward. It is also easier to load balance and decenteralize your database to different locations.

There are many more nuances to the pros and cons, in the end it relates to how much data will be handled. If you are handling 1/2 million documents+, you probably should not be storing them in the same database as Odoo/OpenERP, they should live in thier own dedicated database with the proper database type, or they should live in a dedicated fileserver.

 

1
Avatar
Buang
gunnar
Penulis

thanks Nigel. Great post.

Avatar
Thierry Godin
Jawaban Terbai

Hello,

I do store attachments for a module I developped (Drop Box like) on file system to keep a light DB. I just do not forget to backup storage folder with the DB.

0
Avatar
Buang
Ray Carnes

is your module available?

Thierry Godin

Module is not available yet. I have to rewrite it, and I have not enough time. Could be done this summer

Menikmati diskusi? Jangan hanya membaca, ikuti!

Buat akun sekarang untuk menikmati fitur eksklufi dan agar terlibat dengan komunitas kami!

Daftar
Post Terkait Replies Tampilan Aktivitas
Attachment icon has disappeared from forms, re-appears under developer mode..? Diselesaikan
database attachments
Avatar
Avatar
1
Des 21
4688
ir_attachment_force_storage then files not found
database filestore attachments
Avatar
0
Agu 18
4466
Confirming that attachments have been moved out of the database into a filestore
database filestore attachments openerp7
Avatar
0
Agu 17
4287
Database disappeared from list after activating Google Oauth for administrator
database
Avatar
0
Jul 25
2253
Attachements
attachments
Avatar
0
Des 24
2174
Komunitas
  • Tutorial-tutorial
  • Dokumentasi
  • Forum
Open Source
  • Download
  • Github
  • Runbot
  • Terjemahan
Layanan
  • Odoo.sh Hosting
  • Bantuan
  • Peningkatan
  • Custom Development
  • Pendidikan
  • Temukan Akuntan
  • Temukan Mitra
  • Menjadi Partner
Tentang Kami
  • Perusahaan kami
  • Aset Merek
  • Hubungi kami
  • Tugas
  • Acara
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Pelanggan
  • Hukum • Privasi
  • Keamanan
الْعَرَبيّة Català 简体中文 繁體中文 (台灣) Čeština Dansk Nederlands English Suomi Français Deutsch हिंदी Bahasa Indonesia Italiano 日本語 한국어 (KR) Lietuvių kalba Język polski Português (BR) română русский язык Slovenský jazyk slovenščina Español (América Latina) Español ภาษาไทย Türkçe українська Tiếng Việt

Odoo adalah rangkaian aplikasi bisnis open source yang mencakup semua kebutuhan perusahaan Anda: CRM, eCommerce, akuntansi, inventaris, point of sale, manajemen project, dan seterusnya.

Mudah digunakan dan terintegrasi penuh pada saat yang sama adalah value proposition unik Odoo.

Website made with

Odoo Experience on YouTube

1. Use the live chat to ask your questions.
2. The operator answers within a few minutes.

Live support on Youtube
Watch now