Skip to Content
Odoo Menu
  • Log ind
  • Prøv gratis
  • Apps
    Økonomi
    • Bogføring
    • Fakturering
    • Udgifter
    • Regneark (BI)
    • Dokumenter
    • e-Signatur
    Salg
    • CRM
    • Salg
    • POS Butik
    • POS Restaurant
    • Abonnementer
    • Udlejning
    Hjemmeside
    • Hjemmesidebygger
    • e-Handel
    • Blog
    • Forum
    • LiveChat
    • e-Læring
    Forsyningskæde
    • Lagerbeholdning
    • Produktion
    • PLM
    • Indkøb
    • Vedligeholdelse
    • Kvalitet
    HR
    • Medarbejdere
    • Rekruttering
    • Fravær
    • Medarbejdersamtaler
    • Anbefalinger
    • Flåde
    Marketing
    • Markedsføring på sociale medier
    • E-mailmarketing
    • SMS-marketing
    • Arrangementer
    • Automatiseret marketing
    • Spørgeundersøgelser
    Tjenester
    • Projekt
    • Timesedler
    • Udkørende Service
    • Kundeservice
    • Planlægning
    • Aftaler
    Produktivitet
    • Dialog
    • Godkendelser
    • IoT
    • VoIP
    • Vidensdeling
    • WhatsApp
    Tredjepartsapps Odoo Studio Odoo Cloud-platform
  • Brancher
    Detailhandel
    • Boghandel
    • Tøjforretning
    • Møbelforretning
    • Dagligvarebutik
    • Byggemarked
    • Legetøjsforretning
    Mad og værtsskab
    • Bar og pub
    • Restaurant
    • Fastfood
    • Gæstehus
    • Drikkevareforhandler
    • Hotel
    Ejendom
    • Ejendomsmægler
    • Arkitektfirma
    • Byggeri
    • Ejendomsadministration
    • Havearbejde
    • Boligejerforening
    Rådgivning
    • Regnskabsfirma
    • Odoo-partner
    • Marketingbureau
    • Advokatfirma
    • Rekruttering
    • Audit & certificering
    Produktion
    • Tekstil
    • Metal
    • Møbler
    • Fødevareproduktion
    • Bryggeri
    • Firmagave
    Heldbred & Fitness
    • Sportsklub
    • Optiker
    • Fitnesscenter
    • Kosmetolog
    • Apotek
    • Frisør
    Håndværk
    • Handyman
    • IT-hardware og support
    • Solenergisystemer
    • Skomager
    • Rengøringsservicer
    • VVS- og ventilationsservice
    Andet
    • Nonprofitorganisation
    • Miljøagentur
    • Udlejning af billboards
    • Fotografi
    • Cykeludlejning
    • Softwareforhandler
    Gennemse alle brancher
  • Community
    Få mere at vide
    • Tutorials
    • Dokumentation
    • Certificeringer
    • Oplæring
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    Bliv klogere
    • Udannelselsesprogram
    • Scale Up!-virksomhedsspillet
    • Besøg Odoo
    Få softwaren
    • Download
    • Sammenlign versioner
    • Udgaver
    Samarbejde
    • Github
    • Forum
    • Arrangementer
    • Oversættelser
    • Bliv partner
    • Tjenester til partnere
    • Registrér dit regnskabsfirma
    Modtag tjenester
    • Find en partner
    • Find en bogholder
    • Kontakt en rådgiver
    • Implementeringstjenester
    • Kundereferencer
    • Support
    • Opgraderinger
    Github Youtube Twitter LinkedIn Instagram Facebook Spotify
    +1 (650) 691-3277
    Få en demo
  • Prissætning
  • Hjælp

Odoo is the world's easiest all-in-one management software.
It includes hundreds of business apps:

  • CRM
  • e-Commerce
  • Bogføring
  • Lager
  • PoS
  • Projekt
  • MRP
All apps
Du skal være registreret for at interagere med fællesskabet.
All Posts People Emblemer
Tags (View all)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Om dette forum
Du skal være registreret for at interagere med fællesskabet.
All Posts People Emblemer
Tags (View all)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Om dette forum
Hjælp

Need a clear explanation on when a development is preferable.

Tilmeld

Få besked, når der er aktivitet på dette indlæg

Dette spørgsmål er blevet anmeldt
questionhelp
1 Svar
2591 Visninger
Avatar
Edouard MORET

Hello,

My Company is setting up odoo, we're gonna use a bunch of modules, with some deep modification as well as so more simple ones.

We hired a company specialized in Odoo to implement it for us.

At first (untill just now) Our demands were really basic (add fields, add existing modules...). But they said that they were doing it in a proper way that is time consuming but preferable.

Today, I wanted to modify a field, to make it a Computed field. (nothing too hard, just a concatenation of 2 fields)

So i went to the modules to find the one which would've implemented the changes we booked before.
But there was none.

What they did was Studio Customisations (so the fields are defined in .xml files, not in a python file)


Am I wrong for thinking they should've done a module inheriting the interface we wanted to modify ?


PS : They knew that at some point we would've needed python devlopment, we told them way before the creation of all these fields.


0
Avatar
Kassér
Karim Kayssi

You can tell them that you noticed that recent customizations were done via Odoo Studio rather than custom modules. While Studio works for small tweaks, it makes future Python-based development, maintainability, and upgrades more difficult.

Since you anticipated Python customizations from the start, you’d like to discuss refactoring current changes into modules and ensuring future customizations follow a module-based approach.

Avatar
Ray Carnes (ray)
Bedste svar

Odoo Studio is best for:

  • low to medium level of complexity features
  • customizations created by individuals
  • rapid development
  • users with a low level of technical skills (scripting)
  • customizations that are mainly for a single Odoo database

Odoo Modules are best for:

  • medium to high level complexity features
  • customizations created by teams
  • traditional development with source control, automated tests, user acceptance phase, etc
  • users with a high level of technical skills (programming)
  • customizations that easily transport between different Odoo databases


Note: both support Python scripting via custom fields and the automation framework.


Another way to think about this:

Odoo Studio is like using off the shelf Lego sets that you don't need to design from scratch that meet generic needs. They come with instructions and are not meant to be modified very much from the original design.

Odoo Modules are like using individual bricks carefully chosen for something tailored specifically to your needs. You write your own instructions and can modify everything and create something highly customized.


See also:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AENTv9r84Ns

0
Avatar
Kassér
Enjoying the discussion? Don't just read, join in!

Create an account today to enjoy exclusive features and engage with our awesome community!

Tilmeld dig
Related Posts Besvarelser Visninger Aktivitet
An error for Invalid fields: Documents Spreadsheet Folder Løst
question help
Avatar
Avatar
2
nov. 25
9420
how to use --without-demo Løst
question help
Avatar
Avatar
1
aug. 25
10869
request for information
help
Avatar
Avatar
1
sep. 25
736
Odoo Online: Setting up an email template that sends to task assignees
question
Avatar
Avatar
1
aug. 25
2742
Hello everyone, I need your help; I want to make a custom header to print my pdf reports.
help
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
4
jun. 25
3129
Community
  • Tutorials
  • Dokumentation
  • Forum
Open Source
  • Download
  • Github
  • Runbot
  • Oversættelser
Tjenester
  • Odoo.sh-hosting
  • Support
  • Opgradere
  • Individuelt tilpasset udvikling
  • Uddannelse
  • Find en bogholder
  • Find en partner
  • Bliv partner
Om os
  • Vores virksomhed
  • Brandaktiver
  • Kontakt os
  • Stillinger
  • Arrangementer
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Kunder
  • Juridiske dokumenter • Privatlivspolitik
  • Sikkerhedspolitik
الْعَرَبيّة Català 简体中文 繁體中文 (台灣) Čeština Dansk Nederlands English Suomi Français Deutsch हिंदी Bahasa Indonesia Italiano 日本語 한국어 (KR) Lietuvių kalba Język polski Português (BR) română русский язык Slovenský jazyk slovenščina Español (América Latina) Español ภาษาไทย Türkçe українська Tiếng Việt

Odoo er en samling open source-forretningsapps, der dækker alle dine virksomhedsbehov – lige fra CRM, e-handel og bogføring til lagerstyring, POS, projektledelse og meget mere.

Det unikke ved Odoo er, at systemet både er brugervenligt og fuldt integreret.

Website made with

Odoo Experience on YouTube

1. Use the live chat to ask your questions.
2. The operator answers within a few minutes.

Live support on Youtube
Watch now