Community mailing list archives

community@mail.odoo.com

Re: A-Z Reporting Tool (Developed By TechOrg) // Promotion

by
SISalp
- 11/24/2015 20:04:09
2015-11-25 1:37 GMT+01:00 Alberto Barrionuevo <abarrio@opentia.es>:
> Uhmmm, may it be considered that Ahmed is already providing the source
> code as AGPL at https://www.odoo.com/apps/modules/8.0/change_tree_view/ ?
>
AGPL requires code publication to all users interacting on line.

> At the end he's is just asking ~200€ "for the service of delivering it",
> what can be considered a fair price and not against free software licensing.

Uncorrect. The price from apps is the price of the module, including
the shop commission, not a shipping price.

>
> AGPL is not saying that you have to deliver the code for free, just as
> free (AGPLed).

I'm afraid it does, thus my and Steephan's warning, regarding version
8, as soon as he publishes it for a try.
Aren't you confusing with GPL ?

>
> Indeed, morally I would consider the 200€ as a contribution to thank his
> efforts.

I have no specific point about this. In addition, a price could be set
to cover a minimal service, support or maintenance. I think there are
many paid modules for V8 which are also downloadable for free, with no
service, either due to AGPL or because their authors trust in
open-source model.
On V9, there is no problem.

>
> Best,
> //Alberto.
> PS: obviously, anybody who gets the AGPL source code, has the right to
> publish it for free anywhere.

Sorry again, in practice, he has the obligation if he puts his Odoo
site on the net.




>
>
> On 24/11/15 22:27, Dominique Chabord wrote:
>> As I warned you previously, and since you put it on line, Stephan is
>> right.
>> You expose yourself to legal suits if you violate AGPL license as you
>> mean to do.
>> Any who would buy from you would have the same obligations.
>> Free software licensing is not an option.
>>
>> 2015-11-24 21:02 GMT+01:00 Ahmed Elsaka <eng.elsaka09@gmail.com>:
>>> Hi Stefan,
>>>
>>> I notified all odoo coummnuty, as the following reasons:-
>>>
>>> 1-  I consider it as added value to odoo product (from my view), so at
>>> least
>>> they have to know the features without testing or buying it
>>> 2- Also I release two free copy for the first two person reply to this
>>> thread, So it is share something with some members in community
>>> 3- I referred that is promotion in subject,
>>>
>>> Thank you,
>>> Ahmed Elsaka
>>>
>>> On Tue, Nov 24, 2015 at 9:41 PM, Stefan Rijnhart
>>> <stefan@opener.amsterdam>
>>> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> On 24-11-15 20:02, Ahmed Elsaka wrote:
>>>>
>>
>>      >
>>
>> cite="mid:CAF4ft9fUbGk5vcpGvkv=e4S8djMbycokLskCFk62hZ+2ufF4bA@mail.gmail.com"
>>      >> type="cite"> >> here is the test link >> >> URL:-
>>     http://178.62.205.89:8069 >> User:- admin >> Pass: admin >> >> >> Hi
>>     Ahmed, >> >> you do realize that by providing network access to your
>>     custom module on >> this AGPL Odoo 8.0 instance, you have just
>>     entitled the whole community list >> to receive the source code of
>>     your module? >> >> Regards, >> Stefan >> >> >> >>
>>
>>          >
>>
>> cite="mid:CAF4ft9fUbGk5vcpGvkv=e4S8djMbycokLskCFk62hZ+2ufF4bA@mail.gmail.com"
>>          >> type="cite"> >> Regards, >> Ahmed >> >> >> On Tue, Nov 24,
>>         2015 at 8:42 PM, Ramiro Silva <tintaecuatoriana@gmail.com> >>
>>         wrote: >>> >>> Hi >>> >>> I would like to test your module >>>
>>          >>> Thanks >>> >>> Ramiro Silva >>> >>> >>> >>> On Fri, Nov 20,
>>         2015 at 9:22 PM, Ahmed Elsaka <eng.elsaka09@gmail.com> >>>
>>         wrote: >>>> >>>> Dear All, >>>> >>>> Here is a surprise for
>>         anyone works on Odoo product, >>>> >>>> TechOrg has developed
>>         A-Z Reporting Module which will enable you to >>>> Custimize,
>>         Design, and Export UNLIMITED Reports from interface without >>>>
>>         needing to write more code, >>>> >>>> Now, By this Module, you
>>         have more than 100000 ready reports, >>>> >>>> For More details,
>>         Watch this Video >>>> >>>> For Downloading it, Here is the
>>         link:- A-Z Reporting Tool >>>> >>>> We always spend great
>>         effort, not only to support Odoo's customers and >>>> users, but
>>         Also to add value to Odoo product, >>>> >>>> GIFT:- I will send
>>         FREE link for the first one who will request it >>>> through
>>         this threat, then he can send me his feedback and can use it for
>>          >>>> personal purpose. >>>> >>>> >>>> Regards, >>>> >>>> Ahmed
>>         Elsaka >>>> >>>> Odoo Functional Consultant >>>> >>>> Mob: -
>>         00201006243796 //(Call & WhatsApp) >>>> >>>> LinkedIn >>>> >>>>
>>         Facebook page >>>> >>>> Youtube Channel >>>> >>>> >>>>
>>         _______________________________________________ >>>>
>
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Mailing-List: https://www.odoo.com/groups/community-59
> Post to: mailto:community@mail.odoo.com
> Unsubscribe: https://www.odoo.com/groups?unsubscribe