Community mailing list archives

Re: Help needed: Wikipedia page deleted

Libertus Solutions, Alan Bell
- 06/26/2015 11:10:00
yeah there were a whole heap of inbound links to the page which were removed, I can't revert those until the Odoo page exists again, which it won't unless notability is established.


On 26/06/15 16:08, Olivier Lenoir wrote:
<blockquote cite="" type="cite">

And this page should be updated with Odoo



Le 26/06/2015 16:58, Ronald Wopereis a écrit :
<blockquote cite="" type="cite">
Excellent work, Alan !
Thx, Ron

2015-06-26 16:42 GMT+02:00 Alan Bell <>:
so, I got hold of the last version of the page and I have been working 
on getting it to a state for reinclusion, you are welcome to help, it 
isn't there yet.

Some notes:
Stuff has to be reliably sourced to a reputable third party, even if 
that makes it out of date or wrong. I changed the number of apps claimed 
to be "more than 3000" even though the real number is closer to 5500. 
The 3000 claim had been referenced in a reliable non-primary source.

Primary sources are a big problem apparently, even the awards listed on 
the Earnst and Young site and the Delloitte site can't be mentioned 
unless a reputable journalistic source unconnected with *both* Odoo and 
the award giver mentions them. So if there was a news article somewhere 
else talking about the awards then great, but pointing to the actual 
list of awards is not OK.

Laundry lists are bad, that was the description of the big list of 
capabilities, it has gone.

Other articles break these rules, that is not relevant. Many other 
articles about ERP software are *shockingly worse* they will probably 
end up being deleted/cleaned up but that isn't our problem and isn't 
relevant to whether this page deserves to exist. Other articles 
reference primary sources all over the place, such as the article about 
wordpress. This also isn't relevant, it seems that articles can have 
some primary references once they have unambiguously established that 
they are a notable topic.


On 19/06/15 15:11, Alexandre Vandermeersch wrote:
> Hello everyone,
> Our Odoo page on Wikipedia has been deleted. We are convinced this is
> completely unjustified.
> > We provided argument against it on, vainly: > > We would need your help to undelete it. > If you are already a contributor to Wikipedia, with good credit, an > admin, or know one who would be willing to help, please get in touch > with me. > > Note: > We don't believe newbies to Wikipedia or people who are too tied to the > matter (like us or strong partners) could help. It might even be > counterproductive as the admin disregard 'Single Purpose Accounts', ie > people who only write on one topic. So please refrain from creating an > account just to enter the debate. We need independent people with proven > contributions to Wikipedia to take the matter further. > > Thanks > Alexandre > > -- > Alexandre Vandermeersch > +32 491 08 80 09 > Chief Marketing Officer, Odoo s.a. > > _______________________________________________ > Mailing-List: > Post to: > Unsubscribe: >

Post to:

Post to:

Olivier Lenoir
13 av de la Porte Chaumont
75019 Paris
09 53 97 60 82

Free software user for 24 years ago
Linux user since 1998, You won't find me on FaceB??!,,,

There is no difference between air conditioning and a computer :
both become useless when you open windows.

Si Microsoft inventait quelque chose qui ne se plante pas ce serait un clou.

Post to: