Community mailing list archives

Re: Odoo v9 Community and Enterprise editions

Fakrudeen Abbaz
- 05/15/2015 06:42:23
Hi Members

Please find below the summarised form of the discussions in Etherpad
“  Odoo v9 Community and Enterprise editions  "

You can update your current stand/opinion on the issue after mentioning your name,  and its not necessary all will agree with you
You can change your decision and views at any point, but please do not change the language from english to any other.
Your comments will be alphabetically sorted.

Its harming the community eco system if all are sending mails with negative comments, so better continue discussion here and only interested members will follow this topic.

Thanks & Regards
Fakrudeen Abbaz, ACMA - ERP Consultant 
Mobile: +97155 66 77 001, skype : fakrudeenabbaz
Sales : 04 295 6615,  Support : 04 295 8986

On May 14, 2015, at 4:43 AM, Anders Wallenquist <> wrote:

Den 2015-05-13 15:12, Raphaël Valyi skrev:
<blockquote cite="" type="cite">
Hello community,

I see a lot of negative reactions with people worried a lot. Well, I think it will do just well.

There will be the AGPL world with all the modules we know and they will keep improving a lot and on the other side there will be another world with a few proprietary modules. If you like OpenERP/Odoo the way it is, you'll just choose that same AGPL world and you'll be just fine.
<blockquote cite="" type="cite">
If instead some people believe because of some marketing that they would be better in the other world with a the few proprietary modules, that's fine. I even think the clear separations of these two world will in fact have a pedagogical virtue quickly and will quickly educate the market to support better the AGPL initiative (OCA etc..) so it will just improve even faster than today, I only see advantages in this.

And ideally the two worlds still collaborate on the LGPL core. Well this is is for me the most worrying point still because that will only work if that master core is public and since a few weeks it has been secretly hidden from what we found. I've read Antony's justification about it, but I think just like Sylvain Legal said, I don't believe the hidden PR had anything to do with what Antony said and we still don't see the master branch moving forward anymore. Well if the core was hidden then of course instead of collaboration there would be a fork on the core, but as for now Odoo SA officially said it was just a technical glitch and there was no intention to not publish the core anymore, so let's wait and see if the git-filter is applied and if things are quickly merged into the master branch again so we can keep collaborating in that essential part.
In other words:

You have to worry about one part that want to create serious bookkeeping and keep this goodies close to their chest and another part that the first part think is doing light bookkeeping. The first part doesn't trust the second part to help them evolv the product doing serious bookkeeping. Do you think the development phase in total will increase or decrease? How long do you think it will take before the two parts will divide and fell apart?


Anders Wallenquist
<blockquote cite="" type="cite">


On Wed, May 13, 2015 at 7:52 AM, Anders Wallenquist <> wrote:
Den 2015-05-12 18:39, Alan Bell skrev:
> On 12/05/15 15:58, Christophe Hanon wrote:
> > I think a licence checker based on dependencies would be great...
> >
> > Regards,
> >
> > Christophe
> >
> my favoured solution too, if we can all agree that in the context of
> Odoo, the best way to interpret the license in terms of the meaning of
> derivative works is through dependencies then it could be set so that
> pretty much anything can depend on LGPL modules, GPL or AGPL can depend
> on GPL modules and only AGPL modules can depend on AGPL modules. This
> dependency rule can be implemented in the code and we could have a
> facility to automatically provide the source
> of the AGPL bits.
> Can anyone see a downside to this?

Well to implement a licence hell are fundamental wrong. If Odoo SA wants 
that Odoo still be a star in free software area the cost of a licence 
hell will kill the community and the product in the long run. To "sell" 
Odoo to new customers you have to look at each module and calculate if 
they will fit together in a licence matter. To create a qoutation 
sometimes a couple of hundred modules have to work together. It's not 
enough that you know its right functionality and you know by experience 
it right for the case, you have to know if any of the other modules 
disqualifies the use of this module in this case. Even if you have 
automatic checks at installation time it will not work. You'll have to 
build the installation before you can create a quotation.

You have to educate your customer what modules they can use and what 
they cannot and why overtime when they want to grow theit business with 

No if Odoo shall remain as a free software product as we know it has to 
have compatible licences in all modules payed or not.

Odoo SA have lost the perspective in this new strategy, this is 
incorrigible stupid and amaturish. I understand what they want - but the 
implementation sucks.


Anders Wallenquist

> Alan.
> _______________________________________________
> Mailing-List:
> Post to:
> Unsubscribe:

Post to:

Raphaël Valyi
Founder and consultant
+55 21 3942-2434

Post to:

Post to: