Skip to Content
This question has been flagged
ormmodelfields.many2onedesign
1 Respondre
7002 Vistes
Avatar
john5000

I've seen a model that has a status or state field which is done as fields.selection() and I've seen it done as a fields.many2one().  Both ways of doing it seem to work fine and do the job. 

I suppose many2one is best when you expect to have new values to add over time. 

I am wondering if there are any best practices as to which should be used under what cirmustances.  And what are the advantages and disavantages of each.  Or any notable experince in using one or the other.

 

Avatar
Descartar
Jérémy Kersten (jke)

Hello Best practice according to me is to use : many2one : for relations with another object (wich can be edited... add choice, ...) Eg: Category, manager, ... Selection : A static list (not evolutive). Eg: Status (Open / WIP / Close) JKE

john5000
Autor

Thank you jke, that is simple and makes sense.

Avatar
Ivan
Best Answer

I wouldn't say that this is best practices, but here are some "differences" that would be your consideration points when making the design decision:

  • selection is a fixed list once rendered (this also applies to many2one fields which is viewed with widget="selection"), you cannot apply domain to it
  • selection will be pulled altogether at once when HTML is rendered (this also applies to many2one fields which is viewed with widget="selection").  Not a good choice if you have hundreds or thousands selection.
  • selection fields (this does NOT apply to many2one fields viewed with widget="selection") is not stored as a Foreign Key.  So you can remove an entry from the selection and no integrity problem will ensue.

As for the states, you can still make it a selection field whilst making it dynamic by supplying the entries from a table.  Selection field can accept a function as selection source.

Avatar
Descartar
Related Posts Respostes Vistes Activitat
How i can verify record then save in Odoo 12?
orm model
Avatar
0
de set. 19
3465
Get model data in a controller Solved
orm model controller
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
4
d’oct. 21
37635
How do I dump all the fields and values in a model (ideally including those from relationships)? Solved
development orm model
Avatar
1
d’oct. 20
12555
Usage of ORM methods and ORM API documentation?
database orm model
Avatar
Avatar
1
de març 15
5038
why res.config model in odoo is TransientModel not Model ?
wizard orm model TransientModel
Avatar
Avatar
1
d’ag. 25
3806